How Music Can Call Back Ex-Catholics

Music in churches should be “beautiful and magnificent”, but also hospitable and accessible to everyone, according to an expert in liturgy.

Christmas is a good time to reach out to people who are distant from the Church with music — but parishes must understand what works. CAROL GLATZ spoke to two experts in sacred music.

’Tis the season for a huge assortment of holiday concerts and carols to choose from, making Advent and Christmas a unique period for reminding people of the evergreen beauty of sacred music.

And music can be that gentle lure that helps welcome and embrace those who have become distant from the Church, said one liturgy and music expert.

Like weddings and baptisms, “Christmas is a great time” to reach out and offer people an experience that encourages them to return to church more regularly, said Paul Inwood, a British composer and former director of liturgy and music for the diocese of Portsmouth.

“When it comes to Christmas, I’m always very aware of the people who perhaps come just once or twice a year” to church, he said.

Christmas Music: Beautiful But Hospitable

For that reason, the music that parishes programme should be “beautiful and magnificent”, but also hospitable and accessible to everyone.

Because “you can’t find anything more religious and more joyful in sacred celebrations than the whole congregation expressing its faith and devotion in song,” Mr Inwood said.

Mgr Vincenzo de Gregorio, who heads the Pontifical Institute of Sacred Music in Rome, said that accessibility means respectfully matching the complexity of the music to the abilities of the congregation so that everyone can participate and feel elevated by the music.

Mr Inwood said before the Second Vatican Council, liturgical music was performed by choirs and the people in the pews were spectators.

“After Vatican II, the kind of liturgy that we had changed its nature and went back to the traditions of the earlier Church when participation in the liturgy was the norm.”

Music was now seen “as a ministry, rather than a performance, and it serves the people and helps them lift up their voices and praise to God”, said the composer.

The people must sing

This push for musical reform was already well underway before the Second Vatican Council, Mgr De Gregorio said, which is why the pontifical institute was founded in 1911 by Pope Pius X. The institute was established to respond to the growing belief that “the people must sing”.

The institute teaches religious and laypeople from all over the world about liturgical music as well as giving them the practical skills to include and promote new forms of artistic expression appropriate to the present culture and people.

The tendency towards inclusion is a unique characteristic of the Latin-rite Catholic Church, said the monsignor, who is an expert in the pipe organ and Gregorian chant, and has degrees in sacred theology and modern literature.

Roman Catholicism was heavily influenced by “the ancient Roman mentality”, he said, which saw that expanding into new territories and spreading its influence meant including and assimilating all that was good and useful from the local cultures.

This history of inclusion “is the secret of the development of music” and all arts, he said.

The Latin-rite Catholic Church “never chose one style. It never said ‘no’” to new developments and allowing instruments, which “for around 1000 years were never used in [Christian] worship because they stank of paganism”.

Instruments First Used By Pagans

Instruments first used by pagan Greece and Rome — like the organ, flute, trumpet and string instruments — are today considered by many to be uniquely sacred instruments, Mgr De Gregorio said.

“In her wisdom,” he said, the Church embraces appealing local traditions and elevates them, finds a way to fold them into the sacred.

That’s why the institute is so important, he said, because the desire for inclusion was never about “wanting to lower the level” of standards, but to skilfully elevate the music of the people to a higher plane.

“Here then is the reason for our school, to create and form people who can make music of the highest level,” he said.

He said he thinks the debate over “folk” versus “traditional” forms of music stems from an “ignorance” about music in general.

Fears that “the Church has abandoned its great music” find fertile ground “where there is no widespread musical culture” in schools and parishes, and people lack basic skills in reading or understanding music, he said.

Problems and polemics occurred, he said, where the reform of liturgical song was “introduced without the necessary preparation”.

The answer, then, isn’t “creating an aristocracy” of experts, but of increasing awareness and preparation for everyone so they can hold onto, develop and appreciate musical traditions.

Two fronts to tackle

Education and formation, both Mgr De Gregorio and Mr Inwood said, have to tackle both fronts: the risk that clergy don’t understand music and its proper expression, and the risk that musicians don’t know enough about liturgy.

Mr Inwood said “there’s a lot of goodwill” on both sides to do the right thing, but people need to understand how music is “integral to the rite and not just an optional stuck on top of it, which is how it sometimes comes across”.

“The music needs to fit the ritual like a glove”, which requires people to understand not just music, but also “what liturgical action is doing so they can tailor the music to what is going on”, a skill not unlike what composers do when fitting musical scores to action unfolding on film or the stage.

Sacred Music Anywhere!

Being respectful of the ritual and sensitive to the congregation means sacred music can shine anywhere — whether it’s a parish in a poor township or in a monumental cathedral, the two men said.

It doesn’t depend solely on resources like a pipe organ or a professional choir, Mr Inwood said, it’s about “authenticity”.

“You can do wonderful things with what you have,” even just a cantor and assembly, he said. “The music isn’t inferior in any way, it’s just different and reflects who the community is at that particular point” and aims to draw them together in praise.

“It’s much better to do [music] you can manage and do it well than try very hard to do things you can’t achieve,” he added.—CNS