Girl altar server: unfair attack

From Catherine Shields, Cape Town

I am an altar server at my school, Springfield Convent in Cape Town, and my parish, Ss Simon & Jude, Simon’s Town. I found Cardinal Raymond Burke’s views on female altar servers (January 14) very unfair.

"Firstly, when you are an altar server, you are there to serve God; you shouldn’t be worrying about anybody else around you. "
“Firstly, when you are an altar server, you are there to serve God; you shouldn’t be worrying about anybody else around you. “

Reading the article, I thought about the feelings I have towards altar serving and what it means to me to serve, and I came to the conclusion that it is a great privilege.

I have also always understood from the gospels that God made us all equal and he gave us talents which we should use.

Now, according to Cardinal Burke, I should give up my role as an altar server because some boys may feel threatened and may not follow a vocation to become a priest because they did not become altar servers.

Firstly, when you are an altar server, you are there to serve God; you shouldn’t be worrying about anybody else around you.

Secondly, what if I developed a vocation to the priesthood? The fact that I could not pursue that is not my fault, I did not make that rule.

Apart from this, serving on the altar does not have to be linked to a vocation. It is a very special experience which draws you closer to God, and this should be available to anybody willing to serve.

Cardinal Burke spends a lot of time, it seems, in analysing male and female roles. In our parish people simply get on with what has to be done, so it is a happy environment where people feel welcome.

I would have thought that the Church needs the involvement of as many young people as possible.


Did you enjoy reading this article or find it helpful? We need your support to continue to bring the Good News to our country, so badly in need of God’s healing hand. Please consider subscribing to The Southern Cross Magazine or becoming a Southern Cross Associate 

Letters Editor
Latest posts by Letters Editor (see all)
Scroll to Top